The company reported a $5 million sales pipeline against a $1 million growth target, which gave management confidence that even a modest conversion rate would deliver the plan
Then the team reviewed its ten largest deals and found that several had no confirmed budget or known decision-maker. Others had remained at the same stage for months, while a few had entered the pipeline after one encouraging conversation
The CRM showed $5 million of opportunity value, but the available evidence supported closer to $1.2 million
“A large pipeline can create confidence without creating revenue”
Pipeline value is not evidence
Sales teams naturally want to keep opportunities alive because removing a deal makes the pipeline smaller and can feel like admitting failure
Weak opportunities therefore remain open, closing dates move from one month to the next and early conversations are assigned values they have not earned. The result is a pipeline that measures optimism rather than likely customer decisions
Account planning and opportunity qualification solve different problems. Account planning identifies which customers deserve greater attention, while qualification determines whether a specific deal is real enough to pursue and eventually forecast
Progress belongs to the customer
Sales teams often measure progress through their own activities, such as holding a meeting, delivering a presentation or submitting a proposal
Those actions may be necessary, but they do not prove that the customer has moved closer to buying. A proposal is not meaningful progress if the customer has not agreed on the problem, budget or buying process
“An opportunity advances when the customer commits, not when the salesperson completes another activity”
Consider a manufacturer evaluating a $250,000 maintenance contract. The opportunity becomes more credible when the operating leader confirms the problem, finance identifies funding, procurement explains the process and management establishes a decision date
Until those things happen, the contract remains possible, but it should not be treated as dependable forecast revenue
Use the Opportunity Reality Check
Every significant opportunity should be tested against five questions. The purpose is not to eliminate uncertain opportunities. It is to represent that uncertainty honestly and identify what must happen before the customer is likely to buy
Qualification question | 0 points | 1 point | 2 points |
|---|---|---|---|
Problem | No clear problem | A plausible need has been identified | The customer has confirmed the problem and its importance |
Buyer | No known decision-maker | A likely buyer has been identified | The decision-maker is engaged |
Budget | No evidence of funding | Funding appears possible | Budget is confirmed or being formally allocated |
Process and timing | No process or date | General timing has been discussed | Decision steps and target date are confirmed |
Reason to win | No clear advantage | Some differentiation exists | The customer recognizes a credible reason to choose the company |
Add the points to give each opportunity a score out of ten
0–3 points: Lead or speculation
4–6 points: Early pipeline
7–8 points: Qualified opportunity
9–10 points: Forecast candidate if the expected decision falls within the forecast period
The score is not a substitute for judgment. Its value is that it forces the team to distinguish what the customer has confirmed from what the salesperson currently assumes
Separate pipeline from forecast
Pipeline includes the credible opportunities the company is pursuing across different stages, while forecast is the smaller portion that management reasonably expects to close within a defined period
A highly qualified opportunity expected to close next year belongs in the pipeline, not this quarter’s forecast. A deal expected to close this quarter but lacking a buyer or budget should not enter the forecast simply because its CRM date says otherwise
Every forecast opportunity must therefore pass two tests
Is there enough evidence that the opportunity is real?
Is there enough evidence that it will close within the forecast period?
This separation allows the company to preserve visibility into early opportunities without depending on them to deliver the current plan
“The pipeline shows what could happen, while the forecast shows what the evidence says is likely to happen”
Check whether the pipeline can support the target
A company rarely wins every qualified opportunity. If the business historically wins one out of four qualified deals, a $1 million new-business target may require approximately $4 million of qualified pipeline:
Required qualified pipeline = Revenue target ÷ Historical win rate
With a 25% historical win rate:
$1 million ÷ 25% = $4 million of qualified pipeline
This calculation becomes misleading when speculative leads are included. Ten million dollars of weak opportunities provides less protection than two million dollars of customer-backed opportunities
Win rates should also be examined by customer type, service and sales route because existing customers, new prospects and public tenders may have very different conversion rates and timelines
Test timing and expected value
A credible opportunity can still fail to support the annual plan if it closes too late
Management should examine when the customer will decide, when delivery will begin and how much revenue will actually be recognized during the planning period. A $500,000 contract beginning in November does not contribute $500,000 of revenue during that year
The same discipline applies to price. An opportunity likely to require a 20% discount should not be forecast at full list price because the forecast should reflect the contract the customer is likely to sign, not the deal the company hopes to sell
Better by Monday
Take the ten largest opportunities in your pipeline and score each one using the Opportunity Reality Check
For every score below two, write down the missing evidence and identify the next customer commitment required to improve it. Then separate the opportunities into leads, early pipeline, qualified pipeline and forecast candidates
Finally, calculate whether the qualified pipeline provides enough coverage using your historical win rate
A smaller honest forecast is more useful than a large pipeline built on assumptions
Until next time …

One practical way to improve your business each week

